David Ricardo's Contribution to the Constitution of the Canon of Ricardian Economics: A Reconsideration of 1970's Interpretations of the 1815 Debate

André Lapidus (1) , Nathalie Sigot (1)

1 PHARE - Pôle d'Histoire de l'Analyse et des Représentations Économiques

This paper reconsiders the debate over the nature of Ricardian economics, chiefly based on the interpretation of Ricardo's Essay on Profits, that raged during the 1970's. This debate opposed a Sraffian view, in the line of Sraffa's 1951 well known Introduction to Ricardo, and a non-Sraffian interpretation, which emerged from Hollander's 1973 article. It is argued that whereas the Sraffa-Eatwell interpretation stresses Ricardian objectivity and comparative statics, Hollander's interpretation stresses Ricardian rhetoric and dynamics. Therefore, both interpretations have too little in common to give rise to an actual debate likely, at least in principle, to give rise to a solution.

Keywords: Ricardo; Hollander; Eatwell; Sraffa; Essay on profits; corn-profit model; production prices; Essai sur les profits; modèle blé-blé; prix de production

Domains: Humanities and Social Sciences; Economics and Finance

André Lapidus, Nathalie Sigot. David Ricardo's Contribution to the Constitution of the Canon of Ricardian Economics: A Reconsideration of 1970's Interpretations of the 1815 Debate. Evelyn L. Forget and Sandra Peart. Reflections on the Classical Canon in Economics, Routledge, pp.270-289, 2001. ⟨hal-00344895⟩